Re: Heres some suggestions

[ Follow Ups ] [ Post Followup ] [ Gunslinger Quake Discussion Board ] [ FAQ ]

Posted by LouZiffer on October 25, 1999 at 16:17:38:

In Reply to: Re: Heres some suggestions posted by Mrman on October 25, 1999 at 15:31:38:

1. better gun models and skins (the 6 shooters looks, well, crappy).

3. no cannon (the cannon sux, how about a rocket launcher type thing instead, maybe built out of a barrel or something).

No no no, Im not saying this is a bad mod, in fact, I like it better than any quake 2 mod out there.
Note: I don't speak for Quintin Stone on this board, he's the mastermind behind this mod. Take what I say as coming from me and me only. The man can certainly speak for himself.

I'm just giving some suggestions

Nothing personal here, but maybe if you'd been a bit more constructive in your criticism you'd be taken more seriously.

For example:
In your first suggestion, you state that the six-shooter looks crappy. Try to explain why. Maybe even have some suggestions about what to do to make it look better. I have no idea what you mean when you say it looks crappy... is it because it's shiny? Is it not realistic? Do you have experience with creating new models and skins that you can lend to the author?

In your third suggestion, you state that the cannon "sux". The same thing applies. There's no reason given, so there is no issue to address. (I tried to guess at what you meant and respond... but I have the luxury of time to do that.)

Also realize that QS is doing this on his own for the most part (and doing it all for free). If you want to pitch in and have a better model or skin for a weapon, by all means contribute. Criticism can equal contribution for sure, but only if it remains constructive.

LouZiffer

Follow Ups:

Re: Heres some suggestions Mrman 18:13:58 10/25/99 (0)

Post a Followup

Name:
E-Mail:

Subject:

Comments:
: :<UL>1. better gun models and skins (the 6 shooters looks, well, crappy).</UL> : :<UL>3. no cannon (the cannon sux, how about a rocket launcher type thing instead, maybe built out of a barrel or something).</UL> : No no no, Im not saying this is a bad mod, in fact, I like it better than any quake 2 mod out there. : Note: I don't speak for Quintin Stone on this board, he's the mastermind behind this mod. Take what I say as coming from me and me only. The man can certainly speak for himself. : I'm just giving some suggestions : Nothing personal here, but maybe if you'd been a bit more constructive in your criticism you'd be taken more seriously. : For example: : In your first suggestion, you state that the six-shooter looks crappy. Try to explain why. Maybe even have some suggestions about what to do to make it look better. I have no idea what you mean when you say it looks crappy... is it because it's shiny? Is it not realistic? Do you have experience with creating new models and skins that you can lend to the author? : In your third suggestion, you state that the cannon "sux". The same thing applies. There's no reason given, so there is no issue to address. (I tried to guess at what you meant and respond... but I have the luxury of time to do that.) : Also realize that QS is doing this on his own for the most part (and doing it all for free). If you want to pitch in and have a better model or skin for a weapon, by all means contribute. Criticism can equal contribution for sure, but only if it remains constructive. : LouZiffer

Optional Link URL:
Link Title:
Optional Image URL:

[ Follow Ups ] [ Post Followup ] [ Gunslinger Quake Discussion Board ] [ FAQ ]